A lady is feeling conflicted after she refused to surrender a few of her late sister’s belongings to her brother-in-law’s daughter.
Posting to the subreddit “r/AmItheA–hole” (AITA) subreddit — a discussion board the place customers strive to determine in the event that they had been flawed or not in an argument that has been bothering them — she wrote that after her sister died, she had left behind a few of her private belongings to provide to her kids.
She wonders if she’s egocentric for not letting her brother-in-law’s daughter put on her late sister’s beloved attire that she left behind.
In her Reddit put up, she defined that her sister had handed away 17 years in the past after battling a terminal most cancers analysis eight months into her being pregnant. After her loss of life, she left behind her 4-month-old daughter, now 17, and a 5-year-old son, now 22.
“After my niece was born she requested me if I might preserve her attire and her favourite jewellery for her children,” she defined. Her sister had collected many good attire from her time working for a style journal which was her prize possession previous to her loss of life.
Her sister wished her daughter to have the ability to have a bit of her, even after she was gone, even when she did not wish to put on the attire. She additionally knew that her husband would remarry after she handed away, and did not need any “traces blurred” if his future spouse and their future kids wished to have her possessions.
She even left behind a necklace for her son, who ended up asking for it and continues to put on it to this present day. In fact, the lady agreed to her sister’s needs.
Her sister’s husband ended up remarrying and having two extra daughters along with his new spouse.
A few yr after her sister died, her prediction got here true and her husband ended up getting one other lady pregnant, after which a couple of months later, married her.
“Issues had been awkward for a couple of years. He was nonetheless a part of our lives however we had not been shut when my sister was alive and his spouse was holding some laborious emotions towards him and us,” she defined, including that his eldest daughter along with his new spouse is 14, whereas their youngest daughter is 9.
The 14-year-old wished to put on her late sister’s costume to a faculty dance.
Her brother-in-law’s daughter had seen a photograph of the lady’s late sister carrying one of many attire and requested the author of the put up if she might borrow it to put on to a faculty dance she had developing.
“He advised me she wished a costume and [asked] me to ship it over with my niece for his daughter. I refused to ship it and he responded by asking my nephew.”
Whereas the lady’s nephew was livid, her niece did not have a difficulty with it, however nonetheless discovered the request from her half-sister to be a bizarre one.
Her brother-in-law argued that it wasn’t honest for her to disclaim his daughter the costume since she’s a part of their household and it should not be an enormous deal. Nevertheless, the lady identified that she is not snug with the thought because it is not what her sister wished for her attire.
When he tried to recommend that his daughter might borrow one of many different attire from his late spouse’s assortment, she advised him that his daughter wasn’t allowed any of them.
“He mentioned I shouldn’t be depriving his daughter and she or he’s being handled unfairly. I advised him these attire had been nothing to do together with her. They’re for my sister’s kids,” she argued.
Most Reddit customers agreed that her brother-in-law’s daughter wasn’t entitled to the attire.
“Your sister was proper that he would get remarried and utterly fail to safeguard the gadgets she wished to go on to her personal daughter. He has confirmed her proper!” one Reddit consumer identified.
Associated Tales From YourTango:
“Stick with your weapons and safeguard these gadgets on your sister’s daughter.”
One other consumer added, “Your sister gave you very particular directions on what to do on this scenario. This was her want and her husband ought to respect it.”
“His children along with his new spouse aren’t your nieces and haven’t any connection in any respect to your sister. He simply sounds grasping, to be trustworthy,” a 3rd consumer chimed in.
Nia Tipton is a author residing in Brooklyn. She covers popular culture, social justice points, and trending matters.